Thursday, February 19, 2009

Mr. and Mrs. Hawthorne Check Out A New Restaurant.

Mr. Hawthorne and I went out today to do a bit of shopping at both Food Lion and Harris Teeter. Country ribs were on sale for 99 cents a pound and I'm interested in entering the Nags Head Ace Hardware Crock Pot Cook Off and I wanted to make a couple of trial runs with ribs, NOT FISH, being prominently featured. Before going grocery shopping, we decided to have lunch first. Important caveat: Never go grocery shopping on an empty stomach when you're hungry. There's a new restaurant in Nags Head we've been wanting to try - Blue Moon Beach Grill. It opened the first week in February but I like to let a restaurant operate for a bit - to get its sea legs, so to speak- before we try it out.
We arrived a little before 12 o'clock and got the last table in the establishment. There was a birthday party going on that took up 2 8-tops, and the other 3 tables were occupied. There were 3 gentlemen at the bar when we got there, and several more ladies came in for the birthday party and sat at the bar. They were extremely busy. That said, the service was excellent and we really didn't have to wait long to be served our meals in spite of the restaurant being totally full.
I ordered a house salad with fried oysters and blue cheese dressing on the side. Baby mixed greens with a a good blue cheese and tough, crappy tomatoes, but then that's to be expected in February. They did note in their menu that their tomatoes were local - fresh from Currituck County- when in season. The oysters? Excellent. Perfectly fried. Plump, juicy, crispy. Mr. Hawthorne ordered a Caesar salad with the fried oysters which is always our bench mark test for restaurants. He liked his dressing, said it was very good, but you already know we make the best Caesar dressing. However, Mr. Hawthorne's complaint was that this was not a true Caesar salad. A Caesar salad has nothing but Romaine, Caesar dressing, perhaps some extra parmesan, and CROUTONS. This salad had tomatoes and bacon in it, and we are both Caesar Salad purists. Now, I like my croutons and so does Mr. Hawthorne. There were no croutons on either salad. Mr. Hawthorne also asked for Tartar sauce and kept saying something was wrong with it. I tasted it and didn't detect anything "off," except perhaps a little more pickle juice flavor. He didn't like it at all.
For my entree, I had the Mahi Mahi, with applewood bacon and a remoulade sauce. I would have liked for my bacon to have been cooked a bit more, but since I didn't eat any except one bite to check it out, it was OK. The Mahi Mahi was a tad overdone and dry in places, but still all right. I attribute it to the fact that the two chefs in the kitchen were slammed. And hey, when I'm cooking for 30-40 sometimes I might miss stuff too. I liked the remoulade sauce. Very good. I never eat the lettuce, tomato, and buns. Too much. I just eat the meat. Now, on to the fries. I like crisp fries. These were typical in-house restaurant fries, in a word, LIMP. Why can't anybody do fries right? If you're going to peel and slice your own fries, then do the ice bath and fry them twice. I want crispy fries. Else, just dump in some good ol' frozen Ore Ida's or give me some potato chips and I'm good to go. Bottom line: Mr. Hawthorne wanted a Caesar salad and the fact that it wasn't a pure Caesar salad really didn't bother him. The oysters were "plump and cooked properly." We will certainly go back again and try something different. I was impressed with the two waitresses who womaned that room with all those people. It was packed. And the service did not suffer at all. Thank you Scott and Melissa. We'll be back.

No comments: